"The worker of the world has nothing to lose, but their chains, workers of the world unite."
-Karl Marx
Mr. Marx, maybe one of the most influential people in the 19th century and definitively somebody that you need to read if you want to debunk the local communists. I will focus on this quote though in this blog and try to take the shoes of the communist. It is fun to switch sides and see it from their point of view.
So, lets imagine that we had a world wide rebellion on our hands and the workers of the world united and they started a revolution that overthrew major governments, anarchy comes and the workers somehow keep the glue on their coalitions and manage their actions perfectly.
What to do now, well we are still going to need food, housing and energy under the new rule and therefore we need some people to go out there and nail that plywood and pick those apples. Well in this new world where GM workers run the world then someone will have to assign the population to assignments.
Now if your that glorious manager of labor in this new order where do you put the previous construction workers? Well they may be best placed in construction, so you do that. Where will the best dairy farms come from? probably Wisconsin. So you dictate to farmers where they move and such and they do so. You repeat this to everyone and also follow Karl Marx beliefs that overproduction is useless and not needed and everyone works to meet quotas.
Well after about two years of rule under the GM workers (Sorry GM, you guys just always come to mind) the cheese farmer will start to make some cheese for his own good, overproduction in Marx theology. He makes some extra and secretly sells it to a gun manufacturer who is in higher demand than that farmer. The manufacturers work of 4 hours yields him about 20 hours of cheese production. This graduates through the economy, you cannot prevent Americans from making extra money on the side, entrepreneurship is natural human nature.
As the accumulation builds up there is an increasing group that can work less time and exchange their products beyond the quotas and become wealthy by buying others labor. Their particular labors are harder to replace, rare or in high demand. The cheese farmer is not in high demand and he thinks the cheese farm Czar and the doctor, who is secretly seeing patients for 1,000 dollars or equal worth of labor on the new black market are somehow the cause of his "chains" He has to work 40 hours to meet his cheese quota and they have to work 40 hours also, but those under the table hours are putting them way ahead of him in money.
The Cheese farmer reads a book called the Communist Manifesto and at this point reads the quote above. He classifies himself as working class and the others as his enemy. He then gains support from the large pool of people who are feel their job is slave work for this ruling class who control everything. They envy the skills and intelligence of the new ruling class who delegates Cheese Farmers and who decides how many hours you should work and where to live.
So he reads the same comment and views the Czars and other government appointed people as the non-workers. He starts a revolution with every backing of Marxism theology and wins. He must now decide where the cheese farmers are to live and their quotas, he also tightens up on the highly skilled fields and sets their schedules. Well eventually the cheese farmer will have to develop management skills to set people in the right field, they will have to develop law skills to write new laws and on and on, eventually they are no longer even considered cheese farmers.
It is not as simple as the workers getting rid of everybody and running the world as they see fit, that the same ideology of the elitist, central planners that we (the workers) are the only real ones who know how this world works and that they can run the world themselves. It is wrong and a commanding finger of communism is not going to stop the natural human tendency for capitalism. This statement sounds like one that creates class warfare in of itself.
Simple math always says that there will be 10% of the population will be the top 10%. Their has to be some hierarchy and social class of things because in actuality it is true, we cannot just really think a cheese farmer is worth as much as a chemical engineer.
The common mistake I see in Marx is that he always thinks that he can just tell the next person what to do in his world. Telling the farmer when to farm, how much and where to send it. Capitalism provides a much better alternative. The Cheese farmer must work, or his competition will run him out of business. he must make great cheese, or cheap cheese to find his place in the market. He will invent new things and make new ways of producing cheese. And the most amazing thing is that he did not even need a cheese czar to write his schedule or tell him where to send the cheese to meet the demand.
Michael G. Morrison
Morrison Marketing
Augusta, Georgia, USA
Michael G. Morrison
Morrison Marketing
Augusta, Georgia, USA
No comments:
Post a Comment